Navigating the ASTM D4541 Pull-Off Strength Adhesion Test: Key Variables and Challenges

ASTM D4541 Standard Test Method for Pull-Off Strength of Coatings Using Portable Adhesion Testers

ASTM D4541 Standard Test Method for Pull-Off Strength of Coatings Using Portable Adhesion Testers was not developed to enable someone to compare a single numerical result from one product to a single numerical result from another product to determine expected performance or equality. There is significant inherent variability in this test method that must be considered when comparing results.

Standard and Scope of ASTM D4541 Adhesion Test 

The Scope of D4541 describes caveats for this test method:

1.2 Pull-off strength measurements depend upon material, instrumentation and test parameters. Results obtained by each test method may give different results. Results should only be assessed for each test method and not be compared with other instruments. There are five instrument types, identified as Test Methods B-F. It is imperative to identify the test method used when reporting results.

Key Variables in ASTM D4541 Pull-Off Adhesion Test (h2)

To determine if two different tests can be compared, the following information is required to be reported in accordance with the standard:

• Date, test location, testing agent,
• Brief description of the general nature of the test, such as, field or laboratory testing, generic type of coating, etc.
• Temperature and relative humidity and any other pertinent environmental conditions during the test period.
• Description of the apparatus used, including apparatus manufacturer and model number, last calibration date, loading fixture type and dimensions and bearing ring type and dimensions.
• Description of the test system, if possible, by the indexing scheme outlined in 8.3 including: product identity and generic type for each coat and any other information supplied and the substrate identity (thickness, type, orientation, etc.).
• Glue used and cure time before test.
• Method used to secure the loading fixture during glue cure, if any.
• Rate of pull.
• Test results.
• Detailed test results as described in Fig. 2, Flow Chart.
• If corrections of the results have been made, or if certain values have been omitted such as the lowest or highest values or others, reasons for the adjustments and criteria used.
• For any test where scoring was employed, indicate it by placing a footnote superscript beside each data point affected and a footnote to that effect with information of the scoring apparatus used at the bottom of each page on which such data appears.
• Note any other deviations from the procedure.

Factors Influencing ASTM D4541 Pull-Off Strength Results

As you can see, there are many variables that are unknown when a single numerical value is reported for adhesion of a coating. Even when these many variables are accounted for and the tests performed in different laboratories in the same manner, the multilaboratory precision of these tests is very low.

Comparing Results Across ASTM D4541 Test Methods 

Tables 1 through 5 of ASTM D4541-22 detail the results of the interlaboratory study of the pull-off adhesion test method. There was one table for each Testing Method, B through F. Each Testing Method represented a different type of test equipment. Table 6 is a summary of the precision of Adhesion Pull-Off Measurements (averaged across coating types for each instrument). In the summary table, The “maximum recommended difference” ranges from 23% to 76%. If you look at each table (summarized below), the variance with each instrument was even larger.

Interpreting ASTM D4541 Pull-Off Strength Variability 

TABLE 1 Comparison of the Average Recommended Difference to the Range of Variation within Each Test

You can see that there were wide variations in the results within each test method.

The Challenge of Comparing Coating Products Using ASTM D4541 Adhesion Test Results

There is another issue (other than the low precision of the test method) that we see with using ASTM D4541 to compare products in the marketplace. As an example, we see specification for linings in a potable water tank that might require a minimum adhesion of say 2,000-psi and the specification call for AWWA D102 ICS 6. ICS 6 is one prime coat of inorganic zinc primer and one coat of epoxy at 10 mils DFT. Is the 2,000-psi adhesion required between the epoxy and the inorganic zinc primer? The adhesion measurement tests provided by the coating manufacturers will most likely have been performed to bare steel which would be completely irrelevant to the application.

Relevance of ASTM D4541 Adhesion Test in Coating Specifications)

When writing specifications for coatings products, it is important to know what is in the standards that you reference and to make sure that performance criteria are relevant to the application being specified.

Understanding ASTM D4541 Pull-Off Adhesion Testing with Help from Sherwin-Williams

Pull-off adhesion tests are essential for evaluating coating performance, but as highlighted by its precision variability, it’s not always a straightforward process. Under ASTM D4541, the multilaboratory precision can vary between 23% and 76%, making it crucial to interpret the results correctly.

Confused? Don’t worry, our water and wastewater experts can help support and guide you throughout your next project. Contact us today!

ASTM D4541 FAQs

What is ASTM D4541? 

ASTM D4541 is a standard test method used to measure the pull-off strength of coatings using portable adhesion testers. It determines how well coatings adhere to a substrate by quantifying the force required to detach the coating from the surface.

What industries use ASTM D4541 pull-off adhesion tests?

Industries that commonly use ASTM D4541 include construction, industrial coatings, oil and gas, marine, automotive, aerospace and any other sectors that require high-performance protective coatings.

What is the difference between ASTM D4541 and ASTM D7234?

While both are adhesion tests, ASTM D4541 measures the pull-off strength of coatings applied to metal, whereas ASTM D7234 is specifically used to assess adhesion of coatings applied to concrete.

What is the difference between ISO 4624 and ASTM D4541?

ISO 4624 and ASTM D4541 are both pull-off adhesion tests for coatings, but ISO 4624 allows for more flexibility in equipment and test parameters, whereas ASTM D4541 focuses on portable adhesion testers with stricter equipment requirements and specific guidelines for interpreting results. ASTM D4541 is more commonly used in the U.S., while ISO 4624 is internationally recognized.

What factors affect the results of ASTM D4541 pull-off adhesion tests?

Factors such as the material being tested, the specific test method used, environmental conditions (i.e., temperature and humidity) and the type of equipment used all influence the results of ASTM D4541 pull-off adhesion tests.